✓ProveIt
Examples / Report #2981245 Saved analysis

("possible") UAF

curl · 2025-02-0710.8s analysis · $0.010 in model calls

What the report claims

Potential Use-After-Free vulnerability in cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free function of libcurl

Compare with curl's recorded outcome

Labeled AI slop

curl's maintainer lists this report as AI slop

Shown for comparison after analysis. The pipeline did not see this label.

ProveIt's finding

Code contradicts the claim

The code provides evidence against the report's central claim. Review the cited lines before deciding.

curl policy: NULL dereferences and crashes
Why this finding?
  • The report misidentifies the free function (cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free) as the site of a use-after-free. The function correctly frees memory; a UAF would be in a caller that uses the pointer afterward, but no such caller is shown in curl's code.
  • The reproduction example is the reporter's own simulation, not actual curl code. The provided curl source shows no call to cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free followed by use of the freed pointer.
  • The project policy lists 'NULL dereferences and crashes' as not security issues when a malicious server can only trigger a crash; this report does not even demonstrate a crash in curl.
What still needs checking
  • A concrete code path in curl where cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free is called and the returned/freed pointer is subsequently accessed.
How this analysis ran 5 claims · 5 citations verified

Checked against curl master on 2025-02-07 (3754115750db). Dev evaluation split. Citation verification checks that a referenced line was in the evidence; it does not prove the model interpreted it correctly.

1 · Grounding
grounded
no model · 4 references checked out, 0 did not
2 · Claims
NVIDIA-Nemotron-3-Nano-30B-A3B
5 claims · 1672 tokens · $0.0002
3 · Evidence
2 code snippets
real curl source at 3754115750db
4 · Judgment
Nemotron-3-Ultra-550b-a55b
6325 tokens · 8.4s · $0.0103
5 · Receipts
5 of 5 citations verified
every citation must point at code the judge was shown
Review a draft reply to the reporter

Edit and verify before sending.

Thank you for the report. The function cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free (lib/cf-h2-proxy.c:208-214) only clears and frees the context — it does not access the pointer after freeing it. A use-after-free would need to be in a caller that uses the pointer after calling this function, but your example code is a standalone simulation, not part of curl. Could you point to a specific location in curl's source where a freed cf_h2_proxy_ctx is accessed?

Inspect all claims and source code 5 claims · 2 code excerpts

Report claims

C1flaw contradicted

Potential Use-After-Free (UAF) vulnerability in the cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free function of libcurl

Read the reasoning

The claim states the UAF vulnerability is *in* cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free. The provided code shows this function only clears and frees the context; it does not access the pointer after freeing it. A use-after-free would have to occur in a *caller* that uses the pointer after calling this function, but no such caller is identified in the report or the provided source.

C2location contradicted

The vulnerability occurs in the cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free function of libcurl

Read the reasoning

Same as C1: the function shown is the free function. The report's example code demonstrates a UAF in the *caller* (trigger_bug), but that caller is the reporter's own test program, not curl code.

C3trigger not verifiable

Accessing the cf_h2_proxy_ctx object after it has been freed

Read the reasoning

The report does not point to any actual curl code path where a freed cf_h2_proxy_ctx is accessed. The provided source only contains the free function definition and main(); no callers of cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free are visible.

C4impact not verifiable

Potential crashes, memory corruption, or security vulnerabilities if exploited

Read the reasoning

Generic impact claims; no concrete exploit path in curl is demonstrated.

C5reproduction contradicted

The example code demonstrates freeing a context object (cf_h2_proxy_ctx) and then accessing it

Read the reasoning

The reproduction code is the reporter's own test program (main() with malloc/free/trigger_bug). It does not exist in curl. The actual curl main() in src/tool_main.c does not allocate or free cf_h2_proxy_ctx.

Read the original report (excerpt)

Full report on HackerOne ↗

Title: Potential Use-After-Free Vulnerability in cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free Function of libcurl Vulnerability Overview: A potential Use-After-Free (UAF) vulnerability has been identified in the cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free function of the libcurl library. This issue occurs when the cf_h2_proxy_ctx object is freed and then accessed shortly afterward, leading to undefined behavior, including potential crashes, memory corruption, or security vulnerabilities if exploited. Impact: Crashes Memory corruption Possible remote code execution or data leakage if exploited in a malicious environment. Steps to Reproduce: Obtain libcurl: Compile and Run the Example Code: Use the simplified code below to reproduce the vulnerability. The code demonstrates freeing a context object (cf_h2_proxy_ctx) and then accessing it, leading to undefined behavior. Example Code: #include <stdio.h> #include <stdlib.h> struct cf_h2_proxy_ctx { int stream_id; void *inbufq; void *outbufq; }; void cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free(struct cf_h2_proxy_ctx *ctx) { if (ctx) { printf("Freeing ctx (stream_id: %d)\n", ctx->stream_id); free(ctx); } } void trigger_bug(struct cf_h2_proxy_ctx *ctx) { printf("Triggering bug...\n"); if (ctx) { printf("Using ctx with stream_id: %d\n", ctx->stream_id); } else { printf("Error: ctx is already freed!\n"); } } int main() { // Simulate creating a proxy context struct cf_h2_proxy_ctx *ctx = malloc(sizeof(struct cf_h2_proxy_ctx)); if (!ctx) { perror("Failed to allocate memory for ctx"); return 1; } ctx->stream_id = 12345; cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free(ctx); trigger_bug(ctx); return 0; } Run the Code and Observe the Output: Upon execution, the following output indicates the cf_h2_proxy_ctx object is being accessed after it has been freed: Freeing ctx (stream_id: 12345) Using ctx with stream_id: 54321 Verify with Valgrind: To confirm the issue, run the program with Valgrind to detect any memory errors: valgrind ./your_program Valgrind Output Memcheck, a memory error detector ("Invalid read of size 4") at 0xxxxxx: by 0xxxxxx: Address 0xxx is 0 bytes inside a block of size 24 freed at 0xxxxxxx: free by 0xxxxxx: cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free by 0xxxxx: main ## Impact A potential Use-After-Free (UAF) vulnerability has been identified in the cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free function of the l …

Source code

lib/cf-h2-proxy.clines 208–214 · definition of cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free
208static void cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free(struct cf_h2_proxy_ctx *ctx)
C1: cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free correctly frees the context after clearing it; the function itself does not access freed memory
C2: The vulnerability location is misidentified; cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free is the free function, not a site of use-after-free
C3: No caller of cf_h2_proxy_ctx_free is shown in the provided source; cannot verify whether any curl code accesses the freed object
C5: The example code in the report is a standalone simulation written by the reporter, not code from curl's codebase
209{
210 if(ctx) {
C1: The function only calls cf_h2_proxy_ctx_clear(ctx) then free(ctx) — no use-after-free in this function
211 cf_h2_proxy_ctx_clear(ctx);
212 free(ctx);
213 }
214}
src/tool_main.clines 236–296 · definition of main
236int main(int argc, char *argv[])
237#endif
238{
239 CURLcode result = CURLE_OK;
240 struct GlobalConfig global;
241 memset(&global, 0, sizeof(global));
242
243 tool_init_stderr();
244
245#ifdef _WIN32
246 /* Undocumented diagnostic option to list the full paths of all loaded
247 modules. This is purposely pre-init. */
248 if(argc == 2 && !_tcscmp(argv[1], _T("--dump-module-paths"))) {
249 struct curl_slist *item, *head = GetLoadedModulePaths();
250 for(item = head; item; item = item->next)
251 printf("%s\n", item->data);
252 curl_slist_free_all(head);
253 return head ? 0 : 1;
254 }
255 /* win32_init must be called before other init routines. */
256 result = win32_init();
257 if(result) {
258 errorf(&global, "(%d) Windows-specific init failed", result);
259 return (int)result;
260 }
261#endif
262
263 if(main_checkfds()) {
264 errorf(&global, "out of file descriptors");
265 return CURLE_FAILED_INIT;
266 }
267
268#if defined(HAVE_SIGNAL) && defined(SIGPIPE)
269 (void)signal(SIGPIPE, SIG_IGN);
270#endif
271
272 /* Initialize memory tracking */
273 memory_tracking_init();
274
275 /* Initialize the curl library - do not call any libcurl functions before
276 this point */
277 result = main_init(&global);
278 if(!result) {
279 /* Start our curl operation */
280 result = operate(&global, argc, argv);
281
282 /* Perform the main cleanup */
283 main_free(&global);
284 }
285
286#ifdef _WIN32
287 /* Flush buffers of all streams opened in write or update mode */
288 fflush(NULL);
289#endif
290
291#ifdef __VMS
292 vms_special_exit(result, vms_show);
293#else
294 return (int)result;
295#endif
296}